beatty_crop.jpg

As more than one rapper has memorably commented, haters are everywhere. Eventually, they were bound to get around to Warren Beatty.

A recent Entertainment Weekly post took aim at the actor’s AFI nomination, charging Beatty with a thin filmography and a late career full of clunkers. We’re not going to defend *Ishtar*—although some have—but judging Beatty by that standard is like judging Michael Caine by *The Muppet Christmas Carol*. Let’s remember the good times, shall we?

His reputation for visionary epics is well-known, but his 70s work in particular stands among the best in American film. *McCabe & Mrs. Miller* set the tone for a decade of transgressive film (as well as dozens of “revisionist westerns” that have clogged arthouses in the decades since), while *Shampoo* (which Beatty co-wrote with Robert Towne) is still one of the best films ever made about either Los Angeles or the 1960s. On the films he’s best known for—*Shampoo*, *Reds*, *Bugsy*—Beatty was involved from all angles: directing, co-writing and producing. His greatest skill was navigating the machinery of Hollywood, and it’s hard to overestimate the effect he had on the industry as a whole from the bombshell of *Bonnie and Clyde* alone.

mccabe_crop.jpg

As he’s settled into the role of Hollywood legend, the list of roles he’s declined has become more impressive than the roles he’s played—the nixed list includes Michael Corleone in *The Godfather*, Butch Cassidy in *Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid*, Gordon Gekko in *Wall Street* and Bill in *Kill Bill*—but if anything, the list is a testament to his restraint. Becoming more selective with age is only sensible, or one risks going the De Niro path. Beatty is just protecting his legacy.

After all, there are a lot of haters out there.

—R.B.

CONTRIBUTORS

  • Russell Brandom